In a surprising move, the Cleveland Browns have signed quarterback Jameis Winston to a one-year deal worth up to $8.7 million, choosing him over veteran Joe Flacco as the primary backup for starting quarterback Deshaun Watson. The decision has sparked controversy and mixed emotions among Browns fans, especially given Winston’s history of sexual misconduct allegations.
Winston, the former No. 1 overall pick in the 2015 NFL Draft, has been under scrutiny since his college days at Florida State University. The controversy dates back to 2012 when Erica Kinsman accused Winston of sexual battery during their time at the university. Despite Kinsman reporting the incident to the police, no charges were pressed, and FSU took no disciplinary action against Winston.
The New York Times reported that Winston settled a civil suit with Kinsman in 2016, just as he was starting his NFL career with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Winston maintained that the encounter was consensual and countersued, alleging that Kinsman was motivated by financial gain. The settlement was reached before the case could go to trial, and Winston’s history of allegations has continued to follow him throughout his career.
The decision to bring Winston to the Browns comes in the wake of Deshaun Watson’s 11-game suspension in 2022 for sexual harassment and misconduct allegations from several massage therapists. Watson’s case involved 22 women, and although a grand jury declined criminal charges, the NFL has not ruled out further punishment if new evidence emerges.
Winston, who spent the last four seasons with the New Orleans Saints, is set to back up Watson in Cleveland. The move has raised questions about the team’s priorities and the potential backlash from fans. Some argue that Winston’s alleged past actions should be taken into consideration, especially in the context of the ongoing controversy surrounding Watson.
Despite Winston’s claims of personal growth and maturity, the decision to sign him over Flacco, who won NFL Comeback Player of the Year last season, has left Browns fans divided. Flacco, who expressed his desire to start but was open to remaining as Watson’s backup, was not offered a contract by the Browns.
General Manager Andrew Berry defended the decision, stating that Winston, at 30 years old, is younger and a better fit for the team’s offensive scheme. The Browns, however, are aware of the potential backlash and will need to navigate the delicate balance of on-field performance and off-field controversies as the 2024 season approaches.
The signing of Jameis Winston, amidst the ongoing allegations surrounding both him and Deshaun Watson, has added a layer of complexity to the Browns’ quarterback situation, leaving fans and the NFL community eager to see how this decision unfolds in the coming season.